Keep walking by.
Old Town Orange is starting to have many good places to eat, but Renata's is not one of them. The Italian food is marginal and the service... what service? I've tried it a couple of times and each time I left disappointed. How can you mess up Angel Hair Pasta with meat sauce? They do. If you like Hamburger Helper with sour cream stirred in atop pasta then this is your place. Other dishes I sampled were so-so, nothing memorable. Also, avoid the patio with cramped quarters and uncomfortable seating.